Russia and Japan’s Island Dispute

On August 13, Vladimir Putin did something he had never done in the 26-years-and counting-of his presidency: he traveled to the island of Iturup (Etorofo in Japanese), the largest of the four disputed islands that Russia calls the Kurils and the Japanese call the Northern Territories. 

The visit looked innocent enough. “What lovely weather you have there, just like a resort!” the Russian president exclaimed, as he set out on a tour of a fish-processing complex, a school, and hospital, and met with the Russian governor of the nearby island of Sakhalin. 

Mr. Putin, however, rarely does something just for the fun of it. Moscow was sending a message: the Kuril Islands are ours; Japan has no right to the northern Pacific archipelago; and Japan is courting trouble with its support for Ukraine in the current war. 

To underscore that message, the day before, Putin donned a camouflage military uniform, boarded a guided missile cruiser, and personally observed a large-scale Russian Pacific Fleet military exercise underway in the Sea of Japan, the Sea of Okhotsk, and the northwest Pacific. Even more to the point, Russian naval groups moved through the La Perouse Strait between the Japanese island of Hokkaido and Sakhalin Island. 

Japan immediately condemned Putin’s visit. Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi called the visit “absolutely unacceptable” and said it “hurts the feelings of the Japanese people,” adding: “We hope that the Russian side will take the seriousness of this matter fully to heart.”

Dmitry Medvedev, Russia’s former president and currently the Kremlin’s online attack dog, was not as diplomatic. Posting on X, he said the islands “were, are, and will remain Russian land. Anyone who fails to understand this will face the monstrous consequences of their delusion.”

I watched reports of Putin’s visit to the Kuril Islands just a few weeks before I traveled to the region by ship. I had been following events in the region for months in preparation for the trip, but it quickly became obvious to me that tensions between Russia and Japan were worsening, especially in the wake of the war in Ukraine.

Historic Wounds

The timing of Putin’s visit struck a deep chord with Japan, coming two days before the eighty-first anniversary of Japan’s surrender ending World War II. But the dispute over the Kuril Islands goes back to the 18th century.

Russian fur traders and explorers had moved since the mid-1700’s eastward across Siberia to the Pacific; Japan was moving northward from its most northerly Island of Hokkaido. In 1855, the two countries signed their first formal border agreement. Japan was given the four islands closest to Hokkaido (Etoforu/Iturup; Kunashiri/Kunashir; Shikotan, and Habomai.) Russia got the islands north of them. Twenty years later, the entire Kuril Archipelago of 56 main islands stretching south from Kamchatka was recognized as Japanese territory. Russia was given control of Sakhalin Island.

The biggest dispute came as a result of World War II.  Japan and the Soviet Union had signed a neutrality pact in 1941, but at the very end of the war, the USSR invaded the Kurils, expelling some 17,000 Japanese residents. In a complex series of agreements and disagreements, Japan renounced control of the Kuril Islands – but, crucially, not the four closest islands to which it had been given legal right under the original 1855 treaty. Russia insisted it had the right to all the Kuril Islands.

As a result of this international legal wrangling, Japan and the Soviet Union never concluded a peace treaty after the war, a situation that continues to this day. Twelve years into his presidency, Vladimir Putin engaged in some attempts to negotiate a settlement of the dispute with then-Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, but the effort failed. 

Putin’s 2022 full-scale invasion of Ukraine sharpened tensions even more. Japan joined Europe and the United States in support of Ukraine and applied economic sanctions against Russia. Moscow retaliated by suspending negotiations with Tokyo over the islands. 

Russia has been backing up its diplomatic claims to the islands with significant militarization of the islands. It has stationed coastal defense missiles, deployed fighter jets, and constructed infrastructure and living quarters for its forces.  A September 2022 detailed report by the Center for Security and International Studies  cites the installation of Soviet-era Tor-M2U surface-to-air missile system in 2015; the 2017 deployment of a Bastion anti-ship missile battalion to Etoforu and a Bal anti-ship missile battalion to Kunashiri; as well as construction of four barracks and deployment of 3,500 troops. That has been further supplemented by  more military construction and additional barracks in subsequent years.

“These missile systems have a range of 310 and 185 miles respectively, allowing the potential to strike most ships coming into or sailing around Hokkaido,” the report notes. 

In a painful development for the islands’ former Japanese inhabitants, Russia has ended visa-free visits. This was not just a tourism-style agreement; it allowed thousands of Japanese to visit their ancestral homes and, more importantly, the graves of their ancestors. 

Future Dangers

Due to a typhoon, my hopes to visit Nemuro, the Japanese city closest to the Northern Territories, were dashed. However, we  sailed close by and down the eastern coast of Hokkaido. The geography of the region, the proximity of Japan and Russia, brought home to me the inherent danger of this unresolved issue. At some points, the distance between territories is just over two miles. Russia’s militarization of the Kurils, along with Moscow’s political posturing, is worrying. What’s more, Russia’s ally, North Korea, is nearby, adding to the tension by launching missiles over or near Japan. Finally, the war against Ukraine is fanning the flames of this dispute unfolding more than five thousand miles away.