A New Storm Gathers
Remarks delivered by Baroness Catherine Ashton for the Sir Winston Churchill Memorial Lecture, held at the Hemicycle in Kirchberg, Luxembourg, on October 29, 2026.
Remarks delivered by Baroness Catherine Ashton for the Sir Winston Churchill Memorial Lecture, held at the Hemicycle in Kirchberg, Luxembourg, on October 29, 2026.
The following remarks were delivered by Baroness Catherine Ashton for the Sir Winston Churchill Memorial Lecture, held at the Hemicycle in Kirchberg, Luxembourg, on October 29, 2026. The lecture was organized by the British-Luxembourg Society in collaboration with the Fondation Nationale de la Résistance.
I am really honored to be here in Luxembourg, a place I mainly associate with Foreign Affairs Council (FAC) meetings held in April, June, and October. It feels great to be back without the pressure of 27 or 28 foreign ministers and institutions, and expectations that were hard to meet. It is lovely to be in this building.
I reread Winston Churchill’s The Gathering Storm to prepare for this lecture. Considering the time that we live in, it seemed most appropriate to draw on his writing. There is a lot to take from it. For this lecture, I want to focus on an early short passage in the book, which I will read in full and then look at in more detail to examine its relevance to what is happening now, and ideas I want to put forward for what we should do.
I should add, by way of giving you some initial cheer, that we do know some of the answers. Whether we have the political will and can prioritize the resources to implement them remains to be seen.
This is the short passage, slightly adapted from his book:
“We find ourselves still confronted with problems and perils not less but far more formidable than those through which we have so narrowly made our way.… It is my purpose, as one who lived and acted in these days, to show…how the malice of the wicked was reinforced by the weakness of the virtuous; how the structure and habits of democratic States, unless they are welded into larger organisms, lack those elements of persistence and conviction which can alone give security to humble masses; how, even in matters of self-preservation, no policy is pursued for even ten or fifteen years at a time…how the counsels of prudence and restraint may become the prime agents of mortal danger… and a quiet life may be found to lead direct to the bull's-eye of disaster.”
Sir Winston spoke of his time, and of course with the benefit of hindsight. Yet, he was a consistent voice arguing for more to be done. He bore witness to the challenges the greatest generation faced— in combating a war many had hoped to avoid, in recognizing the depth and breadth of the determination of those who waged war, and the inability or unwillingness to accept the challenge to avoid it in the first place.
No two times are the same. No challenge or threat exactly alike. History rhymes rather than repeats. But as Faulkner also says, “the past is never dead, it is not even past.”
Let me begin by describing a sadly familiar present. A storm has gathered, bringing war again to Europe, waged by an aggressive Russia, with little sign of a real peace in sight. Two weeks ago in Warsaw, listening to Zelensky speak to the Polish Prime Minister and many other politicians and military leaders from Central and Eastern Europe, I heard a bleaker and more disheartened story than any I have heard before. Winter is coming. It will be extremely tough for Ukraine to sustain itself. Money and weapons are running low. Political support, while solid in many places, is uncertain in others.
Additionally, there is a war in the Middle East, with no sign of an end. The Strait of Hormuz now in play, is not a cause of the war, but creating energy instability, fueling prices and inflation across the world. It is interesting that in both these wars, the consequences are far-reaching to some of the most affluent and poorest nations alike.
The challenge of trying to bring peace in the Middle East is compounded by a lack of coherence about why this war with Iran began. The specifics seem to vary, and without clarity of purpose, there can be no clarity of resolution. Points that should be obvious in a Negotiation 101 course.
In both these conflicts, the effects of rising prices feed into populations tired of the same old politicians peddling the same old answers and attracted by the quick, easy and seemingly bold ideas from fake news, disinformation, or the counsels of despair and disillusionment.
And of course, far, far from resolved, but rippling through communities all over the world is the horror of October 7, 2023, and the terror perpetrated on Israelis, followed by the shocking destruction and death in Gaza. Winter is coming there too.
These wars knock other crises off our media spotlight. The worst humanitarian crisis in Sudan, being exacerbated by outside forces playing out a regional proxy conflict. On the one side, the United Arab Emirates, wanting to control ports and to counter political Islam, while on the other, Egypt wanting to protect Nile security, and prevent a refugee crisis on their doorstep getting worse with over a million Sudanese already crossing the border.
And there are an estimated 50 plus armed conflicts across Africa – according to the Red Cross – for example in the Sahel, in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and in Somalia.
Overall, across the world, there are about 120 active armed conflicts, including drug cartels, gang-related violence, and 56 major state-based wars – the highest number of countries in conflict since World War II. I wonder what Churchill would have thought of this. He would have looked to alliances and partners and the major powers of the world, perhaps.
I would often say, with little sense of foreboding in those days, in my time in Brussels that there were three powers in the world capable of inflicting real damage on Europe.
Russia with its military, grey/hybrid and disinformation warfare; China with its massive economic force able to wreck parts of our economy making us dependent upon it; and the USA in both respects. Militarily, the United States of America could weaken us by failing to live up to the bargain of NATO, or by refusing to supply us with weapons or help and make financial or territorial demands, using tariffs as a political weapon, wreaking havoc on our economies.
I would joke that we should try hard not to end up with all three in a bad place. Yet here we are. I would argue there is probably more to be done with China. We have some leverage. For China, the destruction of the European economy or Europe having to put all its resources into fighting a war with Russia is not in its interests. But there is no coherent strategy focused on the long-term relationship and role Europe might take with China. In the UK, we went from Golden Age to Ice Age in a short period of time. Now is the time to become more sophisticated in our thinking, set up the dialogues properly, take the economic threat seriously, and look for collaboration perhaps through the latest five-year plan that works for us, as well as act against the unfair challenges.
But Putin has no interest in talking to the EU and while he might understand now that there can be no resolution with Ukraine without engaging Europe, rather than, as he sees it, leaving it to be decided by the two great powers of USA and Russia. But he remains determined to get some kind of win against Ukraine and feels he has an ally in the USA and a friend in China in achieving that objective.
We shall see where the latest discussions take us. But talk across the Atlantic of further reducing sanctions against Russia, and the uncertainties around American intelligence, the slowing of Star Shield, whether by Elon Musk or the White House, the slowness in granting the license for Patriot missiles, the delays in supplying weaponry that Europe is now purchasing – they all add to the unease of where we are. Add to that the echoes of Russian calls for Zelensky to go, and it feels like dangerous territory. Whether the discussions between Putin, Jonas Storre, and Alex Stubb have achieved any breakthrough or at least started a dialogue that is European remains to be seen.
Add to the promises being made about restarting war with Iran after the midterms in the USA, and our international scene looks grim indeed.
***
So, what can Churchill tell us?
“The structure and habits of democratic states, unless welded into larger organisms lack those elements of persistence and conviction which can give security”
The global order as we think of it, is under pressure, and the strains are felt in the organizations we have created since WWII, especially the United Nations, and, to a lesser extent, the NATO and the EU. Yet, as Churchill says, without the collaboration of others, no problem can be resolved. Not the war in Ukraine, or climate change, migration challenges, trade and economic growth, safety and security, pandemics. None.
It is obvious that the UN, and especially the Security Council, is unable to achieve much, though they unanimously extended the Sudan sanctions regime in September. For reasons we could debate it is apparently easier to get the permanent members – China, Russia, US, UK, and France – to come together on issues affecting sub-Saharan Africa than any others.
I should add that the only time the five permanent members of the UNSC came together and worked together for years, despite other crises, was in the JCPOA, which I chaired and led for four years. Despite the beginnings of the crisis in Ukraine, economic challenges with China, and disagreements about what was needed in the deal, they stuck together throughout. It was not a bilateral deal but a multilateral one that only could have been achieved under the auspices of the UN and under the leadership of the EU. And I pay tribute to all those who contributed to its success. It is interesting now how much the often maligned JCPOA is held up as a sort of gold standard against which to judge any agreement likely reached with Iran at the end of this current conflict. If only they had left it alone and built on it. It was never meant to be the only deal, but rather the first, after which by building some confidence in the ability to negotiate further, and using incentives and pressure it is not impossible that more could have been done to help bring more security to the region. Wishful thinking? Perhaps, but I would have liked us to try.
We should remember that the UN with its peacekeeping, focus on international law, and continued support in areas of conflict, is still valued in much of the world. While it may feel missing in action in both Ukraine and the Middle East, it is hampered by the realities of the UN Security Council, and the failure to update its structures. Organizations that fail to reflect changes risk irrelevance at best and destruction at worst. Any future for the UN must include an understanding that there needs to be change, if it is to find a more effective role in the future.
But – and it is a big but - the UN, like the EU and NATO, are the tankers in our world. They travel slowly, heavily through the water, weighed down by values, ideals, a legal framework. They require nations to sign on the line, committing money, people, time to get long term effectiveness into the world’s crises. They are complex and difficult. bureaucratic and costly. But they keep going. They don’t need to refuel often, stay at sea, and steadily look to their destination, big enough to weather major storms. You get my drift.
Contrast them to the yachts. The coalitions of the willing, who come together to address one problem, with little in common beyond that. No signing of anything, a simple agreement to work together for one cause. Different values and ideas but common purpose. They can travel fast for short periods, change direction easily, get from one place to another. But they can’t stay in the water and if the wind drops, or the weather changes, well they are stranded. They are important, but insufficient to resolve problems. Good at getting an immediate crisis under control, but we need the tanker to arrive to address the longer term effects.
And we are seeing more general cargo ships entering the water. They are versatile, able to handle mixed goods, and move through choppy water, carrying some bulk. They are the G7, meeting annually to coordinate economic policy, and discuss security issues; possibly the G20 and perhaps increasingly the BRICS dominated by Moscow. With the addition of Nigeria, the BRICS-plus is over half the world’s population. But this is definitely mixed cargo. Countries participate for lots of different reasons, with different expectations and certainly not driven by the same values. Some are democracies – notably Brazil, India, South Africa. Some are definitely not: China, the UAE. Some pretend to be: Iran and Russia.
Regardless of any specific example, we need different types of vessels to do different jobs. But there is an indispensability about the tankers. We should scrub off the rust, and barnacles, give them a new coat of paint and keep them going – albeit perhaps more slowly than before for a while.
***
Churchill wrote… unless welded together “lack those elements of persistence and convictions which can alone give security “
Mark Carney threw down a challenge in Davos, inviting middle powers and other smaller countries to protect their interests through greater cooperation. He described what he termed a “rupture” in the world order due largely to changes in US foreign and economic policies. Canada has been on the receiving end of much of this. Who would have thought that Canada would be seen as anything less than a solid, reliable partner to the USA?
Is this a potentially new ship or vessel? It is an interesting thought for European nations, especially those in the EU. Do they consider themselves middle powers, or part of a middle power, or, as I believe, do they see the EU as a much more significant power than it projects on the world stage? In my six years in Brussels, I was constantly surprised at our inability to stand tall as a massive economic power, and potentially an equally strong foreign policy power. In part, the desire of member states to retain their own sense of importance and relevance – that is not so much about sovereignty – and the institutions’ desire to consolidate its power through bureaucracy and regulation. Setting up a new quasi-institution was a privilege but, in all candor, it was against a hostile background from all sides of the EU.
Churchill talked about “the structure… but also the habits… of democratic states, unless welded into larger organisms” ….
Structures need to be living things, not static objects born of one place and time. Habits, or the way things are always done, need to be challenged and changed to fit the world as it is, not as it was. Different institutions vying with each other for power and responsibility is a healthy tension, but can quickly become an inward-facing battle, rather than an outward-facing strength.
Would the EU together with the UK, Norway, Switzerland, Japan, South Korea, Australia, and Canada, to name just a few, see the potential in allying alongside each other, politically and economically? Would this be a super yacht, brought together at a time of dramatic change eventually becoming a big cargo ship, travelling alongside the tankers as far as it could? Or is this a structure too far, weakening the existing organizations? A charge often laid at the EU in its desire to boost its defense commitments, by those who worry such actions might weaken NATO.
***
“How even in matters of self-preservation, no policy is pursued for even 10 or 15 years at a time…
Churchill understood that problems need time to be resolved and the willingness of organizations and nations to focus for long periods was difficult to achieve. According to him, it was one of the reasons for the failure to prevent WWII.
Time in democracies is measured in four to five year periods. One election to another. Occasionally, with strong majorities, governments also talk of ten years. Andy Burnham in the UK has described some of his policies on, for example, social care for elderly people, as being based on an implementation period of ten years. But it is vanishingly rare. There was a time when the center ground could be relied on to form the land connecting political parties from left and right, even though they wanted to demonstrate clear blue water between them. Now it is just water, and choppy water at that.
The problem is most crises bubble up over time, sometimes decades or longer before erupting. Resolving them takes at least as long.
Why would it be the case in Afghanistan, that one or two generations of girls going to school would fundamentally change a system that has been for decades (if not centuries) established on the assumption that women were to be denied education? How could it survive even a few months after we left?
Decades of difficulty from Somalia to Haiti has led to gang warfare, government collapse, the rise of fundamentalism, and destruction of communities. This in its turn led to challenges to our way of life, from piracy off the coast of Somalia, perpetrated by largely teenage boys on the promise of $10,000 if they got a ship, versus, maybe one dollar if they could find a job. It wrecked our trade and the World Food Programme, cost many hundreds of millions to cover insurance, and put in place military and civilian missions to halt, deter, imprison, and disband the pirates. There are no excuses we should make for their actions, rather it is about our failure to see it and deal with it early.
And there is longevity in issues left unresolved that fester and deepen and are used to support the perpetration of crimes even centuries later. During meetings between the Prime Ministers of Serbia and Kosovo, in reaching the Brussels Agreement, I proposed June 28 for a meeting. Both Prime Ministers immediately leapt to their feet, in argument and song, pointing out this was the date of the Battle of Kosovo, which represented a fundamental fracture between them. “When was it?” I asked, “1389” they replied. It might as well have been yesterday.
One of my top ten lessons in negotiation is “Time.” Everything takes longer than you imagine. I spent four years negotiating with Iran. I didn’t begin those talks, and even after a few weeks, I didn’t conclude them. We don’t build enough time into our willingness to engage and solve problems for the longer-term.
This is where our tankers come in. Part of the purpose of creating these institutions is to be able to put in place strategies that last longer. By allowing their work to be the dry land upon which we can all stand, we allow them to focus on the longer term, making decisions that will affect our security in the future. It is no surprise, therefore that one of the outcomes of WWII was a desire to build these organizations and protect them. We damage them at our peril.
***
“How the counsels of prudence and restraint may become the prime agents for mortal danger… and a quiet life leads straight to the bullseye of disaster”
Problems may begin somewhere, but they don’t stay there. They move, across nations, regions, continents, and the globe. Climate change is a factor for all of us in Europe, with a challenging summer behind us and winter storms yet to come. But in some parts of the world, it is fast making whole swathes of countries impossible to live in. Nothing grows; nothing can survive. People need to move. Add to that the number of crises and problems, from war and chaos to natural disasters and economic failures, and we see a planet on the move.
Pulling up drawbridges to protect our “castles; failing to find ways to support each other as we grapple with the consequences of people movement or failing to see that cutting development support means those countries tackling these problems on the front line can no longer do so – these are all features of the counsels of restraint, and the quiet life. And where does it lead us?
Let us take a small example of Chad. A land-locked, hot, poor, vulnerable country that took in 250,000 refugees between July 2024 and June 2025. They joined the 1.5 million that Chad was already supporting. Low and middle income nations host over 70-percent of the world’s refugees. They rely on richer countries and the resources of the UN and EU to help them cope; especially to help them keep the refugees close to home, in the hope that if the conflict ends, they will be able to go back to their own country. Yet, aid has been cut, sometimes quite savagely.
Aid and development are never a popular subject, partly because people believe nations spend much more than they do. Opinion polls and focus groups regularly put spending on aid at the bottom of the priority list, so it is an easy win for governments in trouble to cut it. No fuss from the voters, no loss of support in the main.
***
“A quiet life may be found to lead direct to the bull's-eye of disaster.”
It underlines the need to make the connection that for most of you is obvious. Foreign policy is Domestic policy. It is simply the means by which some of your domestic policies are enacted – better economy through trade and opportunity; safety and security through international intelligence and policing; more chances to travel safely through diplomatic and consular services; and so on. And nowhere is the connection more obvious in trying to solve problems before they become crises. Churchill believed that had more effort been made, for longer, by governments working together, with determination and purpose, the war could have been averted.
We have to stick at it. As Winston Churchill says, “irrespective of the ebb and flow of national politics.”
Which brings me to my final point.
Across the world we are witnessing the rise of politics that disparages the old ideas of center, left and right, preferring, as I mentioned earlier, to put forward radical, sloganized responses to the tough questions our citizens face. Voters are fed up. They have elected governments who have, in their minds, failed them. In Europe, the younger generation has suffered from long-term effects of the pandemic, and is unable to buy their homes, has fewer job opportunities and is staring down the barrel of AI, which threatens to wreck their chances of getting on the ladder of employment in the first place. Their parents worry that their generation will be less well off than they were.
Crises as far back as the Arab Spring, as we call it, were sparked by the young man in Tunisia who was unable to feed his family and could not pay to get the permit the police suddenly demanded for his fruit and vegetable stall. Mohammed Bouazizi set fire to himself and died two weeks later. Young people across the region, many of them highly educated, took up the call of wanting governments free from corruption, jobs and opportunities. They called for the same things every other community on earth wants: security, a home, a job, education for their children, and a future which has huge helpings of happiness.
The world feels uneasy. Europe feels uneasy. I suggest that it has felt uneasy since the financial crash in 2008, when people felt poorer, but the banks that caused the problems got bailed out and ended up richer. Nobody went to jail. Disillusioned publics are willing to take chances that would have been considered impossible 20 or even ten years ago. Why not? Fed a diet of echo-chambered disinformation, they see traditional politics as worn out at best or corrupt at worst. So why not try something new – especially as the horrors of the past fade into history or are simply unknown. “What is this place,?” asked an aspiring member of an EU member state parliament as we visited Wannsee Villa, where the implementation of the final solution of European Jews was organized.
The ebb and flow Churchill described has become stormier and harder to navigate. Yet we know that, at the margins, the offer being made to the people will not stem the tide of problems that crash onto the shore. Rather, it will become worse. And we know where that can end.
As Churchill said at the beginning of the short passage, “we find ourselves still confronted with problems and perils not less but far more formidable than those through which we have so narrowly made our way.… the malice of the wicked reinforced by the weakness of the virtuous.”
We know the answers, or at least some of the problems, and we can identify the perils. We can map out a journey together and we must. Standing for the values we believe in is not a weakness but the heart of our strength. Churchill stood firm against difficult, almost impossible odds. We should do the same.