Skip to main content
Support
Blog post

Only 93 Countries of the Human Rights Council’s 193-member General Assembly Voted to Suspend Russia

Ambassador Mark Green
Human Rights and Alliance of Civilizations Room of UN
GENEVA - MAY 15, 2010: The Human Rights and Alliance of Civilizations Room in the United Nations Headquarter in Geneva, Switzerland. Its ceiling decorations call for peacefulness.

In the UN General Assembly Vote that Suspended Russia from the Human Rights Council, only Ninety-Three of One Hundred and Ninety-Three Members Voted in Favor of Suspension.

Led by the U.S. and Europe, on April 7, the UN voted to suspend Russia from the Human Rights Council. While supporters cited the vote as evidence of “rallying the world” against Russia and its war on Ukraine, details suggest that more work is needed.

Ninety-three member nations voted in favor of suspension. But that means—despite plenty of evidence of human rights violations—that most of the General Assembly did not. In fact, if not for the abstention of 58 nations, supporters wouldn’t have been able to claim the two-thirds majority necessary for suspension. Twenty-four nations voted against the resolution.

Among those who abstained were nations who attended last year’s Summit for Democracy in Washington, most notably India, which imports much of its defense technology from Russia, and has declined to enforce sanctions. Indonesia, Brazil, and South Africa were also among the abstentions. So was Mexico, whose president criticized the UN before the vote, saying the organization should have acted as an intermediary rather than exclude Russia. 

After the vote, Russia’s Deputy Permanent UN Representative, Gennady Vladimirovich Kuzmin, announced that Russia had "already decided” to leave the Council and accused some members of complicity in other countries’ human rights violations. “In spite of their membership as members of the Council, they are not ready to sacrifice their short-term political and economic interests in favor of true cooperation and stabilizing the human rights situation in certain countries,” Kuzmin announced in the statement of resignation.

China, one of Russia’s close allies, voted against the resolution, fearing the divisive consequences and "dangerous precedent” of the decision. Other opponents included Cuba, North Korea, Nicaragua, and Venezuela.

The UN Human Rights Council, whose charter demands that members “uphold the highest standards in the promotion and protection of human rights,” has long included members who have been frequently accused of human rights violations. For example, Venezuela, Cuba, and China are currently members.

About the Author

Ambassador Mark Green

Ambassador Mark Green

President, Director, & CEO, Wilson Center
Read More