Turkey: The Struggle for Its Future
NATO ally Turkey, long a stable, reliable and pluralistic Western partner has been shaken by a swirl of corruption allegations. In the lead up to the March 30 municipal elections, seen by many as a referendum on his leadership, Prime Minister Recep Erdogan has responded with mass dismissals and censorship, including attempts this week to ban Twitter and YouTube. In this Ground Truth Briefing, three experts discuss the implications for Turkey and the region.
Turkey: The Struggle for Its Future
Summary of the Call
It has been a trying year for the Turkish Prime Minister, Recep Erdogan, as he and his administration have come under numerous political attacks. However, after facing popular protests in Istanbul last summer and a high-level corruption scandal only a few months ago, the PM has passed a key test of confidence, as his Justice and Development Party (AKP) won majority support in the country’s municipal elections on March 30.
Speaking from Istanbul two days after the municipal elections, Dr. Gulnur Aybet stated that, although the AKP has seemingly cemented its grasp on power, the key question is, “what will they do now?” She expects Erdogan to now move on with some “deep state cleaning,” in which Erdogan and his allies will attempt to apply new checks and balances of power on entrenched bureaucrats as well as implementing institutional reforms, targeting the judiciary, intelligence agencies, and other aspects of government. Further, given the unity the AKP has demonstrated throughout this year of conflict, she expects Erdogan to stand as the sole AKP candidate in upcoming presidential elections.
In Ankara too – where opposition parties have contested the vote – Dr. Bulent interpreted the vote as a victory for PM Erdogan. Results are showing that support for the AKP has increased since last election – this time winning roughly 45% of the vote. Dr. Bulent believes that Turkey will continue its historical trend of slowly “moving from crisis to reform.” It is his hope now that, with this demonstration of support for Erdogan, politicians will be able to advance an array of economic and political reforms resulting in a stabile and democratic Turkey “within a year or two.”
Like the other speakers, Ambassador James Jeffery also saw this vote as a significant victory for Erdogan, and a sign that both his pursuit of a “majoritarian government” and his rhetoric against international and domestic powers will go unchanged. However, the Ambassador also suspects that Erdogan’s domestic agenda could meet some resistance, particularly any attempts he makes to reform the country’s constitution. However, these potential domestic problems become secondary when considering the increasingly “heavy foreign policy agenda” that involves Turkey.
If the U.S. and it allies hope to make any gains in Syria, they will need Turkish support and cooperation. Similarly, Amb. Jeffery believes that Turkey can and should play a key role in enforcing regional stability, exercising its influence in Iraq and amongst the region’s Kurdish population. Further, he acknowledged the growing potential for a joint energy deal between Turkey, Israel, and Cyprus, that could further sow regional stability and further diversify the EU’s energy supply, and lower its dependence on Russian gas.
With all these initiatives in mind, it is important the Western leaders do not judge Erdogan too quickly. These are tough political times and in order to succeed, Western leaders will need to strike a balance so that we can pursue our vital interests while respecting our values and respecting our allies in Turkey.
Professor of International Relations, Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences at Sabancı University, Istanbul, Turkey
Ambassador James F. Jeffrey
Christian F. Ostermann
Woodrow Wilson Center
Global Europe Program
The Global Europe Program addresses vital issues affecting Europe’s relations with the rest of the world through scholars-in-residence, seminars, international conferences and publications. These programmatic activities cover wide-ranging topics include: European energy security, the role of the European Union and NATO, democratic transitions, and counter-terrorism, among others. The program also investigates comparatively European approaches to policy issues of importance to the United States, including migration, global governance, and relations with Russia, China and the Middle East. Read more